“Okay, so this is a rather ridiculous thing and I'm not entirely sure where to begin.
There's this guy (let's call him the a), whom I used to date. We were friends first, then he confessed that he wanted something more, and I agreed because I already liked him. And honestly, it was nice. Sweet, sometimes embarrassingly cringe, but nice. It mattered to me.
Then came the breakup. Except it wasn't exactly a straightforward breakup. There were misunderstandings, people getting involved, things being said through other people, and apparently a whole lot of assumptions. One particular guy, who had liked me for years, apparently told the Idiot that I liked someone else. I don't know exactly how much that influenced things, but it became part of the mess.
The actual breakup was indirect and confusing. I heard that he wanted to end things from other people, while he himself seemed confused. I didn't understand what was happening, and instead of communicating properly, I reacted emotionally. I said things I didn't mean, sometimes out of frustration, sometimes because I genuinely didn't know what to do. I regret some of that, especially if I made him believe I didn't care. Because I did. A lot.
And then there's the aftermath. Letters, conversations, friends trying to patch things up, information travelling through approximately seventeen different people, and somehow even a four-page letter that became its own mystery. There have been moments where it seemed like we might finally talk, but we still haven't really sat down and heard each other's sides.
Meanwhile, the school has apparently decided that one complicated situation wasn't enough, so there have been other confessions, another guy who liked me for years, an anonymous senior leaving notes, and various other subplots. It's honestly ridiculous. If people just spoke to each other, half of this school's lore would cease to exist.
But underneath all the comedy, I think the a situation is the one thing I haven't quite made peace with.
I don't know if I want him back, or if I miss who I thought he was, or if I miss what we had before everything got so complicated. I do know that I miss the person I knew before all the misunderstandings. And if he's still that person, I think I'd want to reconnect.
I don't necessarily expect things to return to how they were. I just wish we could have one honest conversation. I want to know what was going through his head, what he believed, how he interpreted everything, and what he remembers about us. Not necessarily to prove anyone right or wrong, but because I feel like we never really got to understand each other.
I know I made mistakes. I can own those. But I don't want to carry the entire weight of something that involved two people.
So, my question is: How do you find closure when nothing ever really ended properly? Is it worth trying to have that one honest conversation, or do you eventually have to make peace with never knowing the other person's side? And how do you tell whether you genuinely want someone back or whether you just miss what once existed?
Also, I promise I'm not usually this dramatic. Or maybe I am. At this point, even I don't know plus what do I do with this anonymous guy cause I’ve got approximately infinite situations and I have no idea what it even is usually I laugh and roast everything but like upon seriously thinking”
✦
Someone answered with kindness...
See.....honestly i feel u are just in love with the version of him who he was before everything turned so badd....yeah one honest conversation one last try wont harm...but if u feel it is not changing...things between u are not changing...its better to let him go...its better to accept things the way it is rather then romanticising the possibility of him changing the way u want....and honestly sometimes closure arent just one last conversation its some time the things that slowly stop bothering u yes im sure u miss him but there is difference loving someone for who they actually are and loving someone who they turned out after are two very different things... idk who u are im just a stranger but honestly....i faced this situation and i can understand this feeling way better then anyone...
And yeah...about that anonymous try finding loop holes and if the dots arent connecting just tell anyone from ur closest friend or parents...be safe.... and dont freak out
I really hope this helped u out
~stranger