Someone once asked...

“I'm 23, and I've never dated anyone before. I've never even held someone's hand romantically before. I've had some past trauma, and I think it has affected the way I approach relationships and intimacy. I have quite a complicated attachment style. I tend to be avoidant, but I'm also anxious. I crave affection and emotional closeness, but when someone actually comes close, I get scared, overthink everything, withdraw and sometimes struggle to accept what I genuinely want. I can become anxious about losing someone while simultaneously creating distance from them. Recently, I met a guy through a mutual friend. For the first time in my life, I found myself genuinely looking forward to talking to someone. I looked forward to his calls, messages and seeing him. We spent around five or six days getting to know each other, but those few days meant more to me than I expected. He was affectionate and thoughtful. He noticed little things about me, took care of me, and made me feel comfortable. Once, when I couldn't finish my food, he took my plate and ate my leftovers. He offered me his pocket to keep my hands warm, hid chocolate in his hoodie pocket, and made several small gestures that I still think about. Most importantly, I held someone's hand romantically for the first time in my life. I was nervous and shaky, but I wanted to hold it. I didn't want to let go. Even after he dropped me home, we stayed on a call for almost two hours because I didn't want the conversation to end. However, there was a complication. He was looking for a potential partner, someone he could possibly build a relationship and future with marriage . I wasn't sure whether I could be that person for him. My family situation is complicated. My family has expectations regarding marriage, whereas I personally don't want to get married or have children. I want independence and the freedom to make my own decisions. I also couldn't promise him a conventional future, and I didn't want to lead him on or make him emotionally invested in something I might not be able to offer. I think I became overwhelmed by the situation. Part of me wanted to continue seeing him, but another part was frightened by the implications and the possibility of things becoming serious. I couldn't simply enjoy what was happening without thinking about what would happen next. At the time, I wasn't entirely sure what I wanted or how to communicate it. But now that he's no longer around, I'm realising how much I miss him. I miss his affection, his little gestures, our conversations and the feeling of having someone to look forward to. I keep thinking about things I wish I had done differently. I even imagined borrowing his hoodie, holding his hand again and spending more time with him. I wish I could have experienced dating him without constantly worrying about marriage and the future. I think what hurts is that I finally met someone whose affection I genuinely wanted to receive, and I couldn't fully allow myself to experience it. Now I feel like I want to reach out and give him closure. I don't want him to think I wasn't interested or that I didn't appreciate the way he treated me. I did. I genuinely liked him. But I also don't know whether reaching out is a good idea, especially when I still miss him and might secretly be hoping for another chance. I don't know whether I'm grieving him, the experience I never got to have, or the possibility of what could have happened between us. My questions are: 1. How do I understand this contradiction in my attachment style? Why do I crave affection so much but become avoidant when I actually receive it? 2. Did I walk away because I genuinely couldn't see a future with him, or because intimacy and the possibility of commitment frightened me? 3. Should I reach out and explain my feelings, or would that only reopen things for both of us? 4. How do I process missing someone I knew for such a short time, especially when this was my first experience of romantic affection? 5. How do I stop feeling that I ruined something that could have been beautiful? I genuinely want to understand myself and learn how to handle relationships differently. I don't want to keep running away from something I want, but I also don't want to promise someone something I cannot give.”

✦

Someone answered with kindness...

1. You might be afraid that if you get it, it will change you, and it will. You're not much in control of who you are now, even on a cellular level, so the illusion of control is unnecessary. No thought is unique, yet no two minds are the same. For the time you're alive, you are you, no matter what changes. What I thought I wanted at 23 is not what I want now at nearly 29. I heard a lot about what he did for you, but not much about what you did for him, mostly intentions. Males live in a very brutal world with little headroom or pity. Instead of worrying about the future pathways you can imagine, focus on the affection you can return today because they're valuable to you. 2. At your age, you have endless options unfolding for your life, and you're at the lowest experience-based qualification you'll ever be to make lifetime decisions. Relationships are more of a daily decision once general compatibility is confirmed. Existentially speaking, we are designed to leave behind copies of ourselves in the living before we die. Because you say you don't want children now doesn't mean that it won't change, but you're kind enough to make a tough decision to protect him (and yourself lol) when you know you can't give him what he wants yet. If you thought you could, and you changed your mind eventually, which do you think is more cruel? 3. If telling him how you felt about these decisions made you bold enough to stay, and he accepted you, my experience is that he is also likely inexperienced and if he somehow buries his desires to accommodate yours, may still eventually resent you for not giving him what he told you he wanted before hearing your thoughts. Relationships involve a lot of negotiation from both sides, so approaching it as, "if you can't ever get xyz from me, what can I do for you to make up for it in a way that satisfies you if that's possible?" works better for future (or current) circumstances. Reaching out will definitely reopen things, but if neither of you is changing, they'll close the exact same way. If your goal is just to deliver information, you can do it in a sweet yet uninviting way, like a handwritten letter mailed to him if you have his address. But if you do want to reopen things, ask to meet up explicitly saying that you want to explain things because you didn't do the best job when you initially had the chance. 4. It happens because it was a set of good memories and they may never leave you for life. Spend enough time with him and you'll get enough bad ones too, that's just humanity. Conflict shows us & others who we really are. It's kind of like a new favourite meal. It becomes what you want until you're sick of it or the recipe changes. The things you like about him may end up feeding the things you dislike. Compatibility is the capacity to manage those expectations satisfactorily for all stakeholders. 5. You did ruin something that could've been beautiful, and there's no nice way around it. But stories don't always end at the bad part. In fact, this conflict may create the foundation you, or you both need to build strong bonds necessary to support such beauty going forward. — from "The Recipe for The Happier Student" (book)

Want to find this sign again?

✦

Others also asked