“For the normal people out there, how do you really feel when encountering someone from a weird niche or subculture (like a juggalo, or a furry, or a hippie)?”

Another soul answered...

I generally ignore them, but sometimes feel pity. All niches are magnets for toxic and manipulative people.

Another soul answered...

as a semi-normal person, do those labels really mean anything? nothing is really objective, things we perceive as "normal" are only deemed that way cause of culture. i think you should just be happy these people have found a place to belong; they don't really need extra judgement in their lives.